TOWN OF MARKHAM PUBLIC LIBRARY

 

Regular Meeting

 

Minutes of Meeting held on Monday, May 31, 2010, 7:01p.m.,

Program Room – Main Level, Markham Village Library – Administration,

6031 Highway 7, Markham

 

Present from the Board:

Ms Cheryl Giblon, Chair

Councillor Alex Chiu

Ms Deborah Jestin

Mr. David Jones

Ms Ada Leung

Mr. Edward McDermott

Mr. Mahendra Naik

Ms Lan Sum

Ms Amanda Turner

Councillor John Webster (from 1.5)

 

Present from Staff:

Mr. Larry Pogue, Director, Administration & Operational Support

Mr. Moe Hosseini-Ara, Director, Service Excellence

Mrs. Jane Byrnes, Board Secretary

Mrs. Diane Macklin, Marketing and Programming Strategist

Ms Angela Tse, Acting Branch Manager, Markham Village Library

 

Regrets:

Mr. Justin Hung, Vice Chair

Mrs. Shamira Madhany

Deputy Mayor Jack Heath

Mrs. Catherine Biss, CEO and Secretary-Treasurer

 

Guests:

Mr. Rajit Raman, Expenditure Control and Purchasing, Town of Markham

Mr. Kishor Soneji, Financial Analyst, Town of Markham

 

 

1.0          AGENDA

 

1.1          Call to Order/Approval of Agenda

 

Moved by:        Mr. McDermott

Seconded by:   Ms Sum

 

RESOLVED THAT:  The agenda be approved.

 

                        Carried.

 

1.2          Declaration of Conflict of Interest

 

None.


 

1.3          Due Diligence

 

The Chair asked the Director of Administration and Operational Support:  Have the taxes and GST been paid and are we in environmental compliance?  The Director of Administration and Operational Support responded:  To the best of my knowledge and belief.

 

1.4          Delegation (Ownership/Linkages)

 

None.

 

1.5        Chair’s Comments

 

The Chair opened her remarks by thanking the Members for attending the Innovation Award for C3 presentation and reception.  The Honourable Michael Chan, Minister of Culture and Tourism presented the award in Council Chambers.

 

The Chair noted the upcoming Senior’s Open House from 2:00 to 4:00 p.m. to be held at Unionville Library and also the Citizenship Ceremony to be held at Markham Village Library on June 30. 

 

On tonight’s agenda there will be discussion on two Ends for final review.  Staff have provided their feedback on “at what cost”.

 

Staff has provided their input to the top five brainstorming initiatives of the Board.  Staff has also highlighted an additional two initiatives to consider.

 

1.6        In Camera

 

2.0          CONSENT AGENDA

 

The Chair asked Board Members if they wished to pull any items from the Consent Agenda.  There were no requests made.

 

            Moved by:        Councillor Chiu

            Seconded by:   Mr. Naik

 

            RESOLVED THAT:   The consent agenda be received.

 

AND THAT:  The Consent Agenda comprising of items:

 

2.1

Approval of Consent Agenda

2.2

Minutes of Meeting  - April 26, 2010

2.3

Communication and Correspondence:

 

2.3.1

Calendar of Events – June 2010

 

2.3.2

Board Newsletter – Number 108

 

2.3.3

“Facility renos part of markham’s rec plan”, Thornhill Post, May 2010

 

2.3.4

Thank you from J. Horne

 

2.3.5

“Celebrating community centre expansion”, Yorkregion.com, April 29, 2010

 

2.3.6

“Thornhill author focuses on local library for next book”, Yorkregion.com, May 20, 2010

2.4

Annual Monthly Policy Review:  (The wording of the following policies are reviewed annually by a Member)

 

2.4.1

GP-2h – Cost of Governance – D. Jestin

 

2.4.2

GP-2i – Ends Policy Review Procedure - staff

 

Are hereby approved as written and the CEO of the Library is hereby authorized and directed to take such action that may be necessary to give effect to the recommendations as therein contained.

 

Carried.

 

Revised Minutes of Meeting – April 26, 2010

 

Moved by:        Councillor Chiu

            Seconded by:   Mr. Naik

 

RESOLVED THAT:  The Revised Minutes of the Meeting held on April 26, 2010 be approved.

 

Carried.

 

(Agenda Item 9.1 Brainstorming was heard at this time.)

 

3.0          CEO’S Report

 

3.1          CEO’S Report – May 2010

 

Moved by:        Mr. Jones

Seconded by:   Ms Sum

 

Other library comparisons on circulation per capita and library space per capita were requested for the next meeting.  Mr. Hosseini-Ara undertook to report back in the CEO’s Report.  Mr. Hosseini-Ara advised that he would only be able to provide the 2008 statistics, 2009 are not available.

 

RESOLVED THAT:  The CEO’s Report be received.

 

Carried.

 

4.0          MONITORING (delegation-ownership linkages)

 

4.1          Compliance list of internal monitoring reports and Discussion Led by Members

 

4.1.1       Executive Limitations:  EL – 2d Budgeting/Forecasting – M. Naik

 

Mr. Naik led the discussion the Executive Limitations EL-2d Budgeting/Forecasting.  He indicated he had a concern from his review of the report but it was answered in the appendices.  He also indicated he did not receive any questions from the Board.

 

Moved by:        Mr. Naik

Seconded by:   Mr. McDermott

 

RESOLVED THAT:  The monitoring report Executive Limitations EL- 2d Budgeting/Forecasting be received.

 

Carried.

.

The Chair commended staff on the reporting detail the Board receives in the reports.

 

5.0          ENDS

 

5.1          Ends Revisions – M. Hosseini-Ara

 

Mr. Hosseini-Ara noted the current version of Ends 1.4.1limits the Canadian experience to be reported in compliance to the Ends.  Many other Canadian experiences could not be reported.

 

The revised version of Ends 1.4.1includes and enriches the Canadian experience in the Library by Canadian authors and other various means. 

 

Moved by:        Councillor Chiu

Seconded by:   Mr. McDermott

 

RESOLVED THAT:   The Board receive the report entitled “Board Ends Review”,

 

AND THAT:  The Board approves the suggested amendment to the Ends Policy 1.4.1 to read:

 

They understand the richness of the Canadian experience.

 

It was noted the revised version would contribute to fulfilling the Ends more completely.  The Board continued to discuss the wording. 

 

Friendly Amendment

 

Moved by:        Councillor Webster

Seconded by:   Mrs. Jestin

 

RESOLVED THAT:  The Board receive the report entitled “Board Ends Review”,

 

The Board approves the amendment to the Ends Policy 1.4.1 to read:

 

1.4.1       They understand the richness of the Canadian experience including, through the eyes of Canadian authors.

 

Carried.

 

Moved by:        Mr. McDermott

Seconded by:   Ms Turner

 

            Discussion arose regarding different types of social media.  Pros and cons were debated.

 

RESOLVED THAT:  The Board approves the addition to the Ends Policy 4.4 to read:

 

4.4          They are engaged through the internet and the use of social media.

 

Carried.

 

It was noted it is up to staff to create and implement the process. 

 

6.0          GOVERNANCE


 

7.0          OWNERSHIP LINKAGE

 

7.1          SOLS Meeting Report – J. Hung

 

Mr. Hung was unable to attend this evening’s meeting.  He advised he would report at the June Meeting.

 

8.0          EDUCATION

 

8.1          Public Sector Accounting Board R. Raman

 

Mr. Raj Raman provided an overview of the Public Sector Accounting Board.  This is a new process the Town is implementing.

 

His presentation highlighted on:

 

            Report on Tangible Capital Assets

            PSAB  - Requirements and Implementations

2009 Draft Financial Statements

            Impact of PSAB on Library Operations

 

There was a discussion on fund raising revenue and how it impacts the budget.  Concern over donations to remain separate from operational expenses was expressed.

 

The Chair thanked Mr. Raman on his informative presentation and asked that he send an electronic copy to the Board Secretary.

 

9.0          INCIDENTAL INFORMATION

 

9.1          Brainstorming Report Follow Up by CEO

 

The Chair referred to the report and noted the top five selected initiatives of the Board plus two additional initiatives were commented on by staff. 

 

Initiative 1

 

Lobby to use power of internet and social networking to develop our library as an expanded network

 

Communication to younger generation through social network e.g. twitter updates

 

The Board discussed initiative 1.  Staff indicated it was a staff function and operational in nature.  Staff will report on the implementation process and timelines of this initiative in the CEO’s Report as it rolls out.  Also it was noted staff’s time on this initiative will be reviewed to see if it is an effective and efficient service vehicle to the public.

 

Initiative 2

 

Lobby to build:  Southeast Branch

                        Armadale

                        Markham Centre

                        Intensification areas

                        (Board Members to prioritize locations)

 

Since the ILMP was recently approved, the Board requested that they be informed if staff encounters any roadblocks in order that they can lobby the issue proactively.

 

Initiative 3

 

Lobby Town Council for funding for Friday night opening.

 

There was discussion on this initiative.  Staff was asked for further information on other libraries:

 

·         If other libraries are open or closed on Friday evening

·         Level of activity of libraries that are open on Friday evening, if feasible

·         The number of central libraries that are open but the local branches closed on Friday evenings

·         How many libraries are open on Friday evening and closed on an alternative time during the week

 

Initiative 4

 

Increase link between library and education system.

 

The Board agreed with the staff’s report.

 

Initiative 5

 

Improve profile of the library

 

·         Services offered

·         Promotion – expand scope

 

The Board agreed with the staff’s report.

 

Initiative 6

 

Lobby for an increase in provincial grants

 

The Board discussed this initiative and requested the following:

 

The number of dollars other library systems are receiving in comparison to their growth.

 

Initiative 7

 

Create Markham Library Foundation, separate from MLB, to coordinate, stimulate and manage fund-raising (including income generated from marketing of C3 System.)

 

 

The initiative was heavily discussed.  Staff reported the CEO will be presenting the Board with a report on this topic since the Library will possible receive revenue from C3.  The Board cautioned the Foundation should be a separate entity from the Board and that the funds received should be a separate fund.  The hospital model could be used as a template.

 

The Chair advised the Board to consider these initiatives.  Staff will present their findings in September and the Board will have a full discussion and decide on the top two or three initiatives.

 

Moved by:        Ms Sum

Seconded by:   Mr. Naik

 

RESOLVED THAT:  The Brainstorming Report be received

 

AND THAT:  Staff will present their findings in September.

 

Carried.

 

10.0        NEW BUSINESS

 

11.0        BOARD EVALUATION

 

11.1      Feedback to the Chair Questionnaire

 

The Chair requested Members to complete the form and return it to the Board Secretary.

 

12.0        ADJOURNMENT

 

Moved by Ms Leung that the meeting be adjourned at 8.47 p.m.