`

 

Report to: General Committee                                             Report Date: February 23, 2011

 

 

SUBJECT:                         March 2011 - Cancellation, Reduction or Refund of Taxes under Sections 357 and 358 of the Municipal Act, 2001

PREPARED BY:              Paul Wealleans, Director, Taxation

 

 

RECOMMENDATIONS:

THAT taxes totalling approximately $455,034.85 be adjusted under Section 357 (in the amount of $374,372.15) and Section 358 (in the amount of $80,662.70) of the Municipal Act, 2001 of which the Town’s portion is estimated to be $98,506.28.

 

AND THAT the associated interest be cancelled in proportion to the tax adjustments;

 

AND THAT the Treasurer be directed to adjust the Collector’s Roll accordingly;

 

AND THAT staff be authorized and directed to do all things necessary to give effect to this resolution.

 



The purpose of this report is to authorize the Treasurer to adjust the Collector’s Roll under Sections 357 and 358 of the Municipal Act, 2001.


 

BACKGROUND:


Sections 357 and 358 of the Municipal Act, 2001 allow for the reduction, cancellation or refund of taxes. Section 357 permits tax adjustments for the following reasons: 

 

·         if a property or portion of a property is eligible to be reclassified in a different class of property, and that class has a lower tax ratio for the taxation year than the class the property or portion of the property was in before the change, and if no supplementary assessment is made in respect of the change under subsection 34(2) of the Assessment Act;

·         property that has become vacant land or excess land during the year;

·         property that has become exempt from taxation during the year;  

·         building that during the year was razed by fire, Demolition or otherwise, or was damaged by fire, Demolition or otherwise so as to render it substantially unusable for the purposes for which it was used immediately prior to the damage;

·         person who was unable to pay taxes because of sickness or extreme poverty;

·         mobile unit that was removed from the municipality during the year;

·         property overcharged by reason of any gross or manifest error that is a clerical error, the transposition of figures, a typographical error or similar type of error, but not an error in judgment in making the assessment upon which the taxes have been levied; or

·         in respect of a property which by reason of repairs or renovations could not be used for its normal use for a period of at least three months during the year. 

 

Section 358 of Municipal Act, 2001 permits applications for tax adjustment by property owners who are overcharged by reason of any gross or manifest error in the preparation of the assessment roll by the Municipal Property Assessment Corporation (MPAC) that was an error of fact, which may include but is not limited to, clerical errors, the transposition of figure or typographical errors, but not an error in judgment in making the assessment upon which the taxes have been levied. These applications relate to taxes levied in each or either of the two years preceding the year in which the application is made.

 

OPTIONS /DISCUSSION:

The attached schedules identify the year of taxation, the assessment roll number of each property, the reason for the tax appeal and the tax adjustment. The tax value includes the Town, Region and School Board share of taxes. There are four main reasons for these applications: (1) “Razed or Demolished” which relates to the demolition of a building on a property that reduced the tax burden. All such applications include a Town Demolition Permit; (2) “Became Exempt”- these are properties that were assessed on the assessment roll as taxable but became exempt during the year. They are properties that either were transferred during the year from a taxable owner to the Town and therefore became exempt from tax (generally lands as part of subdivision agreements) or lands purchased by a school board and became exempt; (3) “Gross or Manifest Error” is the result of errors by the Municipal Property Assessment Corporation (MPAC) on the assessment roll which caused an overcharge of taxes, (4) “Classification Correction is where the property or a portion of the property was eligible to be reclassified in a different class of real property. For example, an industrial property class changed to commercial.

There are 16 applications listed that have no associated tax adjustment. These are applications reviewed by MPAC and determined to be not eligible for relief.

 

FINANCIAL CONSIDERATIONS:

The Town of Markham’s portion of taxes for the taxation years 2007 through 2010 is estimated to be $98,506.28. The amount of taxes adjusted for both the Region of York and School Boards will be reflected on the 2011 payment submissions to these bodies.

 

 

Tax Adjustments under Section 357 /358  of the Municipal Act

                        Town

$98,506.28

                        Region

$188,955.49

                        Education

$167,573.07

Total

$ 455,034.85

 

 

Sufficient funds are available in the Tax Write off Account No. 850 850 7051.   

 

 

 

 

 

 

HUMAN RESOURCES CONSIDERATIONS:
Not applicable

 

ALINMENT WITH STATEGIC PRIORITIES:

Not applicable

 

BUISNESS UNIT CONSULTED AND AFFECTED:

None

 

 

 

 


RECOMMENDED BY:

Microsoft Office Signature Line...     Microsoft Office Signature Line...

 

 

 

ATTACHMENTS:

Appendix A – “Tax Adjustments”

Appendix B – “Tax Adjustment Under Section 357 & Section 358 of the Municipal Act, 2001

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

                                   

Appendix A

 

 

Tax Adjustments Under the Municipal Act

For March 7, 2011

General Committee Meeting

Finance Department

 

 

Report Total

Description

Amount

Count

Razed Demolished

-$210,182.89

12

Became Exempt

-$115,711.78

22

Gross/Manifest Error

-$92,780.32

16

Classification Correction

-$15,210.54

2

Overcharged by Error

-$13,054.28

28

Ceased to be taxed

-$5,800.38

1

Error in assessment Roll Prep

-$2,096.24

1

Damaged by Fire/Demolition

-$198.42

2

No Recommendation

$0.00

16

Grand Total

-$455,034.85

100

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


 

 

Appendix B

Tax Adjustments under the Municipal Act

For March 7, 2011 General Committee Meeting

Tax Appeals: Section 357 – Residential

Tax Year

Application #

Roll Number

Property Address

Reason

Remark

Total Amount

2008

3522

36-03-0-212-52400

4757 14th Ave

Became Exempt

Place of Worship

-$6,288.76

2008

3652

36-03-0-260-44096

2665 Bur Oak Ave

Became Exempt

Place of Worship

-$1,493.35

2009

3724

36-03-0-212-52400

4757 14th Ave

Became Exempt

Place of Worship

-$6,480.44

2009

3794

36-0-30-214-68214

0 Penny Royal St

Became Exempt

Transfer to Town

-$10.09

2009

3821

36-03-0-222-22942

0 George Martin Dr.

Became Exempt

Transfer to Town

-$10.09

2009

3788

36-03-0-232-60910

180 Mingay Ave

Became Exempt

Place of Worship

-$6,646.92

2009

3650

36-0-30-237-07800

10235 Highway 48

No Recommendation

RfR completed

$0.00

2010

3830

36-0-10-040-10306

5 Shieldmark Cres

Razed Demolished

Pool Fill in

-$149.58

2010

3798

36-01-0-087-85500

16 Blue Spruce Lane

Razed Demolished

Fire. Home damaged

-$586.41

2010

3810

36-0-20-110-05445

47 Holsworthy Cres

Razed Demolished

Pool Fill in

-$52.51

2010

3805

36-0-20-112-30759

114 Holm Cre

Overcharged by Error

Lot size adjustment

-$160.02

2010

3831

36-0-20-114-00297

62 Suncrest Blvd

No Recommendation

Not assessed for parking

$0.00

2010

3846

36-0-20-133-49194

26 Glamorgan Crt

Razed Demolished

Pool Fill in

-$57.50

2010

3816

36-0-20-152-55785

0 Woodbine Ave

Became Exempt

Transfer to Town

-$1,719.54

2010

3818

36-0-20-152-55786

0 Woodbine Ave

Became exempt

Transfer to Town

-$4,176.06

2010

3811

36-02-0-170-49300

99 Babcombe Dr

Razed Demolished

Pool Fill in

-$89.58

2010

3809

36-0-20-170-56500

46 Laureleaf Rd

Razed Demolished

Pool Fill in

-$54.27

2010

3790

36-02-0-171-38700

43 Fairway Heights Dr

Razed Demolished

House demolished

-$1,396.36

2010

3796

36-0-20-214-68214

0 Penny Royal St

Became exempt

Transfer to Town

-$9.63

2010

3792

36-03-0-211-08175

2 Kelvin Rd

Razed Demolished

Fire. Home damaged

-$1,755.27

2010

3849

36-0-30-211-86322

106 Marydale Ave

Overcharged by Error

Two properties consolidated into one

-$509.34

Tax Year

Application #

Roll Number

Property Address

Reason

Remark

Total Amount

2010

3782

36-03-0-212-08026

26 Billingsly Cres

Overcharged by Error

Basement area adjustment

-$582.82

2010

3808

36-03-0-225-97354

71 Central Park Dr

Razed Demolished

Vehicle Impact. House Damaged

-$775.12

2010

3789

36-03-0-232-60910

180 Mingay Ave

Became Exempt

Place of Worship

-$6,777.06

2010

3814

36-0-30-235-07000

6418 Major Mackenzie Dr

Became Exempt

Transfer to Town

-$4,729.98

2010

3815

36-0-30-252-66837

0 Ninth Line

Became Exempt

Transfer to Town

-$722.50

2010

3772

36-0-30-252-97784

0 Box Grove Coll Rd

No Recommendation

Transferred to the Town by Mplan. Apportionment received for this property. 357 not necessary.

$0.00

2010

3838

36-03-0-253-47108

0 Ninth Line Rear

Overcharged by Error

Wrong Model Used

-$2,095.26

2010

3884

36-0-40-350-65707

14 Sir Bedever Pl

Overcharged by Error

Lot size adjustment

-$28.90

2010

3887

36-0-40-350-65709

16 Sir Bedever Pl

Overcharged by Error

Lot size adjustment

-$178.22

2010

3890

36-0-40-350-65710

18 Sir Bedever Pl

Overcharged by Error

Lot size adjustment

-$250.47

2010

3893

36-0-40-350-65712

20 Sir Bedever Pl

Overcharged by Error

Lot size adjustment

-$72.26

2010

3881

36-0-40-350-65720

36 Sir Bedever Pl

Overcharged by Error

Lot size adjustment

-$144.50

2010

3866

36-0-40-350-65721

38 Sir Bedever Pl

Overcharged by Error

Lot size adjustment

-$279.37

2010

3878

36-0-40-350-65723

42 Sir Bedever Pl

Overcharged by Error

Lot size adjustment

-$81.89

2010

3832

36-0-40-353-50064

8 Brookfield Crt

No Recommendation

Pool not assessed

$0.00

Total

36 Properties

-$48,364.07

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Tax Appeals: Section 357 – Non-Residential

Tax Year

Application #

Roll Number

Property Address

Reason

Remark

Total Amount

2005

3350

36-0-20-110-18800

288 John St.

No Recommendation

Value already reflects demolition

$0.00

2007

3658

36-0-40-371-50800

6579 Highway 7

Razed Demolished

Building Demolished

-$5,415.86

2008

3582

36-0-20-150-36400

2938 Major Mackenzie Dr

Became Exempt

Transfer to Town

-$19,216.86

2009

3758

36-0-20-110-21000

360 John St

No Recommendation

ARB Decision-stopping manufacturing is not a change in use

$0.00

2009

3756

36-02-0-111-21000

1 Steelcase Rd

Classification Correction

Partial change in use from Ind to Com

-$6,887.32

2009

3764

36-0-20-113-70700

750 Cochrane Dr

No Recommendation

No Recommendation

$0.00

2009

3822

36-02-0-126-64973

3980 14th Ave Unit 3

Overcharged by Error

Building size adjustment

-$2,086.94

2009

3759

36-02-0-126-75200

8241 Woodbine Ave

Razed Demolished

Building Demolished

-$3,625.16

2009

3854

36-0-20-136-43200

2832 16th Ave

No Recommendation

No Recommendation.

$0.00

2009

3583

36-0-20-150-36400

2938 Major  Mac Dr

Razed Demolished

Transfer to Town

-$28,126.45

2009

3795

36-03-0-214-68213

0 Penny Royal St

Became Exempt

Transfer to Town

-$48.29

2010

3850

36-0-20-110-21000

360 John St

Razed Demolished

Building Demolished

-$196,225.27

2010

3840

36-0-20-121-42194

166 Torbay rd #4

Overcharged by Error

Change in Use from Ind to Com

-$1,038.23

2010

3820

36-0-20-132-39000

275 Renfrew Dr

No Recommendation

Renovation do not reduce assessment value

$0.00

2010

3834

36-0-20-139-03910

0 Cox Blvd

Became Exempt

Transfer to Town

-$985.09

2010

3861

36-0-30-212-97000

5933 14th Ave

Classification Correction

Change in Use from Ind to Com/Res

-$8,323.22

2010

3797

36-03-0-214-68213

0 Penny Royal St

Became Exempt

Transfer to Town

-$44.98

2010

3833

36-0-30-220-32035

0 Richard Mayn Cres

Became Exempt

Transfer to Town

-$13.19

2010

3819

36-0-30-233-44069

0 Castlemore Ave

Became Exempt

Transfer to Town

-$337.17

2010

3812

36-0-30-233-68100

9999 Highway 48

No Recommendation

Buildings still standing

$0.00

2010

3817

36-0-30-252-66838

0 Markham Bypass

Became Exempt

Transfer to Town

-$394.98

2010

3752

36-0-40-371-50800

6579 Highway 7

Overcharged by Error

Building Demolished

-$25,758.72

Total

22 Properties

-$298,527.73

 

Tax Appeals: Section 357 – PIL Residential

Tax Year

Application #

Roll Number

Property Address

Reason

Remark

Total Amount

2008

3556

36-0-20-113-25050

0 Bayview Ave

Became Exempt

Town Purchase

-$5,721.18

2009

3734

36-0-20-126-89900

0 Warden Ave

Became Exempt

Town Purchase

-$21,759.17

Total

2 Properties

-$27,480.35

 

Total:

Section 357

60 Properties

-$374,372.15

 

 

Tax Appeals: Section 358 – Residential

Tax Year

Application #

Roll Number

Property Address

Reason

Remark

Total Amount

2007

3521

36-03-0-212-52400

4757 14th Ave

Became Exempt

Place of Worship

-$6,112.30

2008

3828

36-0-10-040-10306

5 Shieldmark Cres

Razed Demolished

Pool Fill in

-$49.19

2008

3803

36-02-0-112-30759

114 Holm Cres

Overcharged by Error

Lot size adjustment

-$159.82

2008

3851

36-02-0-132-86377

18 Muster Crt

Overcharged by Error

Lot size adjustment

-$167.98

2008

3847

36-0-30-211-86322

106 Marydale Ave

Overcharged by Error

Two properties consolidated into one

-$228.32

2008

3780

36-03-0-212-08026

26 Billingsly Cres

Overcharged by Error

Basement area adjustment

-$577.44

2008

3774

36-0-30-252-63514

10 Coakwell Dr

No Recommendation

Equity does not constitute gross or manifest error

$0.00

2008

3824

36-0-30-252-99775

191 Box Grove Bypass

Overcharged by Error

Wrong model used

-$136.48

2008

3509

36-0-30-253-75700

7960 Reesor Rd

No Recommendation

Split completed in 2008

$0.00

2008

3882

36-0-40-350-65707

14 Sir Bedever Pl

Overcharged by Error

Lot size adjustment

-$31.49

2008

3885

36-0-40-350-65709

16 Sir Bedever Pl

Overcharged by Error

Lot size adjustment

-$178.48

2008

3888

36-0-40-350-65710

18 Sir Bedever Pl

Overcharged by Error

Lot size adjustment

-$251.97

2008

3891

36-0-40-350-65712

20 Sir Bedever Pl

Overcharged by Error

Lot size adjustment

-$73.49

2008

3879

36-0-40-350-65720

36 Sir Bedever Pl

Overcharged by Error

Lot size adjustment

-$146.98

2008

3864

36-0-40-350-65721

38 Sir Bedever Pl

Overcharged by Error

Lot size adjustment

-$283.47

Tax Year

Application #

Roll Number

Property Address

Reason

Remark

Total Amount

2008

3894

36-0-40-350-65722

40 Sir Bedever Pl

Overcharged by Error

Lot size adjustment

-$209.97

2008

3876

36-0-40-350-65723

42 Sir Bedever Pl

Overcharged by Error

Lot size adjustment

-$83.99

2009

3829

36-0-10-040-10306

5 Shieldmark Cres

Razed Demolished

Pool Fill in

-$149.23

2009

3804

36-02-0-112-30759

114 Holm Cres

Overcharged by Error

Lot size adjustment

-$160.61

2009

3858

36-02-0-113-26145

25 Times Ave 2111

Overcharged by Error

Assessed for extra parking space

-$12.61

2009

3852

36-0-20-132-86377

18 Muster Crt

Overcharged by Error

Lot size adjustment

-$166.49

2009

3848

36-0-30-211-86322

106 Marydale Ave

Overcharged by Error

Property Consolidation

-$502.59

2009

3781

36-03-0-212-08026

26 Billingsly Cres

Overcharged by Error

Basement area adjustment

-$582.71

2009

3775

36-0-30-252-63514

10 Coakwell Dr

No Recommendation

Equity does not constitute gross or manifest error

$0.00

2009

3825

36-0-30-252-99775

191 Box Grove Bypass

No Recommendation

Adjustment incorrectly applied.

$0.00

2009

3826

36-03-0-253-47108

0 Ninth Line Rear

Overcharged by Error

Wrong model used

-$2,096.24

2009

3786

36-0-30-258-05731

23 Cornwall Dr

No Recommendation

No Error

$0.00

2009

3883

36-0-40-350-65707

14 Sir Bedever Pl

Overcharged by Error

Lot size adjustment

-$30.27

2009

3886

36-0-40-350-65709

16 Sir Bedever Pl

Overcharged by Error

Lot size adjustment

-$179.10

2009

3889

36-0-40-350-65710

18 Sir Bedever Pl

Overcharged by Error

Lot size adjustment

-$252.26

2009

3892

36-0-40-350-65712

20 Sir Bedever Pl

Overcharged by Error

Lot size adjustment

-$73.16

2009

3880

36-0-40-350-65720

36 Sir Bedever Pl

Overcharged by Error

Lot size adjustment

-$146.31

2009

3865

36-0-40-350-65721

38 Sir Bedever Pl

Overcharged by Error

Lot size adjustment

-$282.52

2009

3877

36-0-40-350-65723

42 Sir Bedever Pl

Overcharged by Error

Lot size adjustment

-$83.25

Total

34 Properties

-$13,408.72

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Tax Appeals: Section 358 – Non-Residential

Tax Year

Application #

Roll Number

Property Address

Reason

Remark

Total Amount

2008

3842

36-0-20-121-42194

166 Torbay Rd #4

Overcharged by Error

Change in Use from Ind to Com

-$955.86

2008

3770

36-0-20-126-76800

230 Yorktech Rd

Overcharged by Error

No Change

$0.00

2008

3750

36-0-40-371-50800

6579 Highway 7

Overcharged by Error

Building Demolished

-$31,841.40

2009

3841

36-0-20-121-42194

166 Torbay Rd #4

Overcharged by Error

Change in Use from Ind to Com

-$984.36

2009

3860

36-0-30-212-97000

5933 14th Ave

Overcharged by Error

Change in Use from Ind to Com/Res

-$5,800.38

2009

3751

36-0-40-371-50800

6579 Highway 7

Overcharged by Error

Building Demolished

-$27,671.98

Total

6 Properties

-$67,253.98

 

Total:

Section 358

40 Properties

-$80,662.70

 

 

Total : Section 357

60 Properties

-$374,372.15

Total : Section 358

40 Properties

-$80,662.70

Grand Total

100 Properties

-$455,034.85