Report to: Development Services Committee Date of Meeting:
SUBJECT: RECOMMENDATION REPORT
Angus Glen Farm Ltd. & Angus
Glen Golf Club Ltd.
Applications for Secondary Plan Amendment,
Zoning By-law Amendment and Draft Plan of Subdivision
Angus Glen Community –
File Nos: OP.03-112028, SU.03-109045 & ZA.03-109048
PREPARED BY:
RECOMMENDATION:
That Phase 1 of draft plan of subdivision 19TM-030004, prepared by G.E.
Hanson Designs, dated April 21, 2006, 2004, to permit 173 single detached lots,
57 townhouse units and 120 apartment units, on the south side of Major
Mackenzie Drive, east of Glenbourne Drive, be approved subject to the
conditions of draft plan approval as set out in Appendix ‘C’ to the staff
report dated June 20, 2006;
That the
Director of
·
That
the Owner shall enter into an agreement with the Town, applying specifically to
the Phase 1 apartment block (Block 351, Plan
19TM-030004), which agreement shall be registered on title, committing the
Owner not to enter into any agreements of purchase and sale with anyone,
including other developers or builders, for the subject block, until the
following conditions have been met:
That the
Secondary Plan Amendment application submitted by Angus Glen Farm Ltd. &
Angus Glen Golf Club Ltd. for lands on the south side of Major Mackenzie Drive,
east of Glenbourne Drive, be approved and the draft Secondary Plan Amendment
attached as Appendix ‘B’ be finalized and adopted;
That the application submitted by Angus Glen Farm Ltd. & Angus Glen
Golf Club Ltd. to amend Zoning By-laws 177-76 and 304-87, as amended, be
approved, and the draft by-law attached as Appendix ‘A’ to the staff report
dated June 20, 2006, be finalized and enacted;
That the applicant agree to pay their proportionate share of
the Hwy. 48 flow control measures, to the satisfaction of the Director of
That Angus Glen Farm Ltd. & Angus Glen Golf Club Ltd. be granted a
servicing allocation of 230 units, in accordance with the
That
the Town reserves the right to revoke or reallocate the servicing allocation
for this development;
That the Region of York be advised of the servicing allocation for this development;
That the applicant provide the Town with the required
payment of 30% subdivision processing fees in accordance with the Town’s Fee
By-law (By-law 2005-357);
And further that the draft plan approval for plan of subdivision 19TM-030004 will lapse after a period of three years commencing the date of issuance of draft approval, in the event that a subdivision agreement is not executed within that period.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY:
The 49.59 hectare (122.53 ac.) property is
located on the south side of
Staff
initially reported to Development Services Committee in May 2003. The original submission proposed only
conventional single detached lots (no rear lanes) and two apartment blocks. Staff indicated that the proposal was a
departure from the
A
public meeting was held in June 2003. Following
the public meeting, a revised plan was submitted to staff comprising of a mix
of conventional product, lane based townhouses, lane based singles and the two
apartment blocks. A second report was
submitted to Development Services Committee in August 2005, and a second
statutory public meeting was held on
·
The size of lots adjacent to
·
Type of and design of the proposed apartment buildings
·
Access to
·
Bridge crossing
·
Need for additional retail within the community
The current Phase 1 draft plan
submission comprises 339 single detached units (70 lane based and 269
conventional product), 60 lane based townhouses, 120 garden apartments, 122
condominium townhouses and 252 apartment units.
The garden apartments are located in the southeast quadrant of the draft
plan adjacent to the golf course. The
second apartment block is surrounded by the condominium townhouses and is
located on the south side of
The
submission includes applications to amend the Secondary Plan and Zoning By-law
and an application for approval of a draft plan of subdivision for Phase 1 of
the proposed draft plan of subdivision.
Phase 1 includes 173 single detached lots (70 lane based, 103
conventional product), 57 townhouse units and 120 apartment units.
Staff
from internal departments and external agencies have reviewed the applications
and worked with the applicant to alleviate issues and concerns identified in
the preliminary reports and at the Public Meetings. Staff are now in a
position to recommend approval of the Secondary Plan Amendment, rezoning and
conditional approval of the application for draft plan approval. The following concerns have been resolved to
the extent possible or covered through the proposed conditions of draft
approval:
Staff acknowledge that including
both conventional and lane based housing products adds to the mix and variety
of housing types available in the community, and on this basis, together with
an acceptable community design, have accepted the conventional product.
FINANCIAL CONSIDERATIONS:
Not applicable
1. Purpose 2.
Background 3. Discussion 4.
Financial
5. Others (Environmental,
Accessibility, Engage 21st, Affected Units) 6. Attachment(s)
This report presents an overview and evaluation of the proposed plan of subdivision (19TM-030004, Phase 1). The report also includes draft Secondary Plan and zoning by-law amendments to permit the proposed development. The report recommends approval of the Secondary Plan, zoning by-laws and the draft plan of subdivision for Phase 1, subject to conditions.
The
49.59 hectare (122.53 ac.) property is located on the south side of
The
subject lands are adjacent to the
The subject lands comprise the
The Region
of York originally approved draft plan of subdivision 19T-95026 on
Three future
phases of development were also draft approved as blocks. These future phases were identified as Blocks
303 (Phase 4), Block 302 (Phase 5) and Block 316 (
The applicant has submitted a
draft plan comprising of 339 single detached units (70 lane based and 269
conventional product), 60 lane based townhouses, 120 garden apartments, 122
condominium townhouses and 252 apartment units.
The garden apartments are located in the southeast quadrant of the draft
plan adjacent to the golf course. The
second apartment block is surrounded by the condominium townhouses and is
located on the south side of
The
Actual unit counts for the East and West Village exceeds Secondary Plan
The Angus Glen Secondary Plan
projected 1,250 dwelling units. The
majority of the
Phase 1 of the draft plan of subdivision includes a mix of singles, lane based townhouses and an apartment site
Phase 1 of the draft plan of subdivision proposes 103 single detached (conventional), 70 single detached (lane based) dwellings and 57 lane based townhouses. The plan includes 6 park/parkette blocks (1.662 ha/4.106 ac) and a 0.648 ha (1.60 ac) stormwater management pond. The plan also includes a 1.29 ha (3.18 ac) High Density apartment site comprised of 120 units. The apartment site does not have any servicing allocation. The zoning for this Block will be appended with a Holding provision and the Owner is required to enter into a “no pre-sales agreement”, pending assignment of additional servicing allocation and site plan approval.
TABLE 2 – |
|||||
|
Area |
Net Density |
|||
|
Units |
Ha |
Ac |
|
|
Gross Site Area |
|
22 |
54.36 |
||
Streets |
|
5.27 |
13.04 |
||
Lanes |
|
0.68 |
1.68 |
||
0.3 Reserves |
|
0.0005 |
0.011 |
||
Walkway |
|
0.049 |
0.121 |
||
Buffer |
|
0.269 |
0.665 |
||
SWM pond |
|
0.648 |
1.602 |
||
Parkettes |
|
1.662 |
4.106 |
||
Singles (lane based 10.7m/35 ft |
36 |
|
|
||
Singles (lane based) 13.1m/43ft |
34 |
|
|
||
Singles 15.2m/50ft |
36 |
|
|
||
Singles 18.2m/60ft |
21 |
|
|
||
Singles 21.3m/70ft |
13 |
|
|
||
Singles 22.8m/75ft |
8 |
|
|
||
Heritage Dwelling 22.8m/75ft |
1 |
|
|
||
Singles – Special lots (0.3 ac) |
24 |
|
|
||
Total Singles |
173 |
12.17 |
30.08 |
||
Townhouses (lane based) |
57 |
1.596 |
3.94 |
||
Total (singles and townhouses) |
230 |
13.406 |
33.12 |
17.1 uph |
6.9 upa |
Garden Apartments |
120 |
1.291 |
3.189 |
92.95 |
37.62 |
The
Angus Glen Secondary Plan designates the lands Low Density Residential, Low
Density – Special Control, High Density Residential, Medium Density Residential
and
The
applicant has submitted an application to amend the Secondary Plan to
accommodate the following proposed revisions to the land use schedule. The proposed amendment covers all phases of
the plan.
· Redesignate the lands containing the Peter Stoeber (Stiver) house (Part of Lot 20, Concession 5) from Low Density Residential to Community Amenity 1, and to include an exception that restricts the permitted uses on the lands to a spa or single-detached dwelling only.
· Introduce the Neighbourhood Commercial Centre as a commercial category within the Secondary Plan (see below).
The
Phase 1 densities of 17.1 units per hectare/6.94 units per acre for the single
detached and townhouse dwellings and the 92.95 units per hectare/37.62 units per
acre for the garden apartment site comply with the Low Density and High Density
provisions in the Official Plan.
The lands are currently zoned Rural Residential
Estate, Agriculture 1 and Open Space by By-law 304-87. A zoning by-law amendment is required to
implement the draft plan of subdivision.
Staff initially reported to
Development Services Committee in May 2003.
As noted previously in this report, the original submission included
only conventional single detached lots (no rear lanes) and two apartment
blocks. Staff indicated that the
proposal was a departure from the new urbanism design of the
A
public meeting was held in June 2003.
The following is a review of concerns raised at the meeting and plan
changes or staff response to each:
The bridge crossing is shown in the Angus Glen
Secondary Plan and is required to provide connectivity between the East and
The
applicant revised the draft plan and incorporated lane based singles and
townhouses, in addition to the large lot product and apartment blocks. In August 2005, staff reported back to
Development Services Committee and recommended that a second statutory Public
Meeting be held, due to the extent of the proposed changes to the plan.
A
second statutory public meeting was held on
Concern was raised with respect to the proposed
walkway to
There was also discussion with respect to the need for
a second signalized access to
The applicant’s traffic study is currently under
review by staff, should any revisions be required as a result of the study, the
plan will have to be red-lined.
A concern was raised with respect to possible
traffic and congestion that may be generated by the proposed residential draft
plan on surrounding roads. A Traffic
Impact Study has been submitted and is being reviewed by the Town. The report indicates that no one individual
local road or laneway approaches the upper end of the acceptable daily and peak
hour traffic volumes. At full build out,
the site and surrounding roads must function at a good level of service.
Residents of the
The apartment sites have not been granted any
servicing allocation capacity. The applicant has indicated that the
garden apartment site will contain two 4 storey buildings. The garden
apartments within Phase 1, adjacent to the golf course are approximately 170
metres from houses in the
The garden apartments will be zoned and draft approved as part of Phase 1. However, the site will be appended with a Holding provision which will not be removed until sufficient servicing capacity is allocated, while the draft zoning by-law (attached as Appendix A) limits the garden apartment to 4 storeys. The Owner will also be required to enter into a “no pre-sales” agreement with the Town, whereby they agree not to pre sell any units in Block 351 until sufficient servicing capacity has been allocated. Staff are satisfied that an acceptable site plan for the garden apartments can be submitted expeditiously once servicing capacity becomes available. Staff have no concerns with draft approving the garden apartment site, subject to the Holding provision and the applicant entering into a “no pre-sales” agreement.
The apartments adjacent to
The Angus Glen Secondary Plan was approved
in 1994 and provides for urban development including single detached dwellings,
townhouses and apartments. Excluding the
4 lots located at the northwest quadrant of the draft plan, which require an
amendment to the Secondary Plan, the proposed lots adjacent to the rural
residential estate lots to the west, have a lot area of 0.12 ha (0.3 ac) with
frontages ranging from 19 m (62 ft) to 33 m (110 ft). This will provide a transition to larger
rural residential estate lots.
In
June 2001, Angus Glen Golf Property Ltd. and Angus Glen Farm Ltd. executed a
site plan agreement for the expansion of an additional 18 hole golf
course. As a requirement of the site
plan approval, Angus Glen is required to include a public access route adjacent
to the
The
walkway is proposed adjacent to the municipal right-of-way on
The
sidewalk on the east side of
This
double row of trees will extend from the proposed stormwater management pond at
the south end of the plan, northward to
Stollery Pond to be reconfigured
In
response to a requirement by the T
These
applications have been circulated to the T
The
size and location of the proposed park spaces have been reviewed in relation to
unit counts and parkland dedication requirements.
The
applicant is required to provide 1.17 hectares (2.89 ac) of parkland for Phase
1 (including the 120 garden apartment units), whereas, the applicant has
provided approximately 1.46 hectares (3.60 ac)(this does not include the
parkettes to be deleted). The proposal
is over dedicated for Phase 1 by 0.293 hectares (0.72 ac) which will be credited
towards Phase 2.
The
applicant is proposing a series of parkettes connecting the two neighbourhood
parks. However, due to a grade
difference between the two parks, the connecting parkettes are not appropriate
in this instance. There is approximately
a 10 metre grade difference between the two parks and the only solution would
be to increase the size of the parkettes or introduce stairs. The Town’s Operations Department has concerns
with respect to maintenance, snow clearing and possible liability issues
relating to the stairs. Therefore, the
applicant is required to red-line the draft plan to delete the parkettes.
Additional
parkland will be required within Phase 2 (to meet overall parkland
requirements) as a result of the deletion of the parkettes. Staff have requested that the parkland be
re-located adjacent to the proposed park Block 355 which will open up the view
to the valley/golf course.
Tree preservation
Phase
1 is primarily open farm fields with small clusters of trees scattered
throughout. There are no notable trees
which are designated for preservation with the first phase. Phase 2 contains a large wooded area
surrounding the Stollery Pond and will be incorporated into the plan as open
space/parkland. A large mature tree has
also been incorporated into a small parkette in Phase 2.
Sufficient servicing allocation to permit draft plan approval of Phase 1
As set out in the February and November 2005 servicing
allocation reports, Council approved 300 units for allocation to Angus Glen
Developments. The applicant
redistributed 70 units of servicing allocation to the Kylemore Post Homes
project (north side of
The allocation is part of a larger regional allocation to the Town, approved by Regional Council in June of 2005. The draft plan has sufficient allocation for the 230 low density units in the first phase.
As a condition of the 300 units of servicing capacity, the Owner is required to construct the bridge crossing as part of their phase 1. A condition of draft approval has been incorporated to require the construction of the bridge.
As noted previously in this report, the garden apartments are being draft approved and zoned, subject to a Holding provision which will not be removed until sufficient servicing capacity is allocated. As a precondition to draft approval, the owner will enter into an agreement not to “pre-sell” any of these units (until servicing capacity is available).
In February, 2005, Markham Council endorsed a proposed flow control option intended to bring the Town’s sewage allocation to a point that would match its current water allocation. Regional Council approved the flow Control option in June 2005.
The applicant will be required to pay $100 per unit as their proportionate share for the cost of the Highway 48 Flow Control System, which is required to create the sanitary sewer capacity for this project.
Sanitary Sewers
In March 2003 a sanitary sewer was
constructed within the
Draft zoning by-law
The attached draft zoning by-laws incorporate the subject lands into appropriate residential zone categories within By-law 177-96. The following are the exceptions that have been incorporated into the zoning by-law amendment:
FINANCIAL TEMPLATE:
Not applicable.
ENVIRONMENTAL CONSIDERATIONS:
The T
ENGAGE 21ST CONSIDERATIONS:
The proposed development promotes a number of key goals set out in “Engage 21st Century Markham” by providing for efficient use of infrastructure, land use patterns and density , compact development and high levels of architectural and urban design.
BUSINESS UNITS CONSULTED AND AFFECTED:
The application has undergone a full circulation. Comments have been incorporated into the report, draft by-law and draft conditions.
CONCLUSION:
The developer has worked with staff to introduce
a variety of housing forms which include lane based product, focussed on a
central neighbourhood park. Staff
acknowledge that including both conventional and lane based housing products
adds to the mix and variety of housing types available in the community, and on
this basis, together with an acceptable community design and support the
proposal. Careful consideration has been given
to the preservation of 3 heritage houses and integrated a pedestrian pathway
system.
Staff are satisfied with the configuration
of the draft plan of subdivision and recommend that the Secondary Plan, zoning
by-law and draft plan be draft approved, subject to the conditions above and in
Appendix ‘A’.
RECOMMENDED BY:
_______________________________ ________________________________
Director of
DOCUMENT: Q:\Development\Planning\APPL\ZONING\03109048 ANGUS GLEN WEST VILLAGE\ReportTemplate_060516_v3.doc
Figure 1- Location Map
Figure 2 – Air Photo
Figure 3 – Site Context and Zoning
Figure 4 – Proposed Draft Plan of Subdivision
Figure 5 – Walkway Plan
Appendix A – Draft Zoning By-law
Appendix B – Draft Secondary Plan Amendment
Appendix C – Draft Conditions
APPLICANT/AGENT:
Angus Glen Farm Limited & Angus Glen Golf Club Limited
Attn: Michael Montgomery
L6C 1N9
Tel: (905) 887-0090 ext. 409
Fax: (905) 887-5197